The 5 Most Popular Bagels You Need to Try



The 5 most popular bagels

Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

The bagel – a timeless classic, an emblem of culinary ingenuity, and a staple of the American breakfast table. Its storied past traces back to 17th century Poland, where it was first savored by the Jewish community.

From humble beginnings the bagel has evolved into a modern marvel, gracing menus and palates the world over.

But what makes this doughy delight so irresistible? We set out to ask several friends and family. I also watched what people are ordering in the store.

Although anecdotal, these are what I’m seeing as the most popular bagels. Although it’s not in my list here, my personal favorite blueberry bagel gets honorable mention as it’s the sixth most popular among those I surveyed.

Let’s explore the top five most popular bagels and uncover the reasons behind their enduring appeal.

  1. Plain Bagel
  2. Everything Bagel
  3. Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
  4. Sesame Bagel
  5. Poppy Seed Bagel

Let’s look at details of each one.

The plain bagel
The 5 Most Popular Bagels You Need to Try 7

Plain Bagel

The plain bagel, often underestimated, is the cornerstone of the bagel world, where simplicity and elegance coalesce into a timeless, mouthwatering treat. Its delicate, yeasty fragrance and delightful chewiness make it a go-to choice for bagel aficionados everywhere.

In terms of nutrition, the plain bagel supplies a dose of carbohydrates and proteins, clocking in at around 245 calories per serving.

Though the unadorned charm of the plain bagel is indisputable, the true beauty of this classic lies in its versatility. Picture a silky layer of cream cheese or a generous swipe of butter melting into its warm, doughy goodness.

If you’re craving a touch of sweetness, a spoonful of jam or honey will perfectly complement its flavors. For the savory-inclined, a lavish layer of avocado or a smattering of smoked salmon will elevate the humble plain bagel to new gastronomic heights. The possibilities are endless, showcasing the plain bagel’s ability to serve as the ideal canvas for culinary creativity.

The Everything bagel
The Everything bagel.

Everything Bagel

The Everything Bagel bursts onto the scene as a bold and audacious alternative to the understated Plain Bagel. Enshrouded in a veil of culinary mystique, its origin story is a topic of debate, with rival claims emerging from the bustling streets of New York and the charming landscapes of Canada.

Regardless of its birthplace, the Everything Bagel is a tantalizing fusion of seeds, garlic, onion, and salt, culminating in a delectable symphony of flavors that dance upon the palate.

Weighing in at approximately 290 calories, the Everything Bagel packs a bit more nutritional heft than its unadorned counterpart.

While cream cheese remains a fan-favorite topping, the adventurous palate may find delight in the exploration of alternative spreads, such as smooth hummus or artisanal flavored butters. The Everything Bagel is a testament to the power of flavor combinations, a celebration of culinary diversity, and a thrilling journey for the taste buds that should not be missed.

The Cinnamon Raisin bagel
The Cinnamon Raisin bagel.

Cinnamon Raisin

The Cinnamon Raisin Bagel emerges as an enchanting oasis of sweetness amidst the bustling landscape of savory bagel varieties. Its tantalizing, warm aroma lures eager taste buds from the moment it graces bakery displays, promising a sumptuous embrace of comforting flavors.

Tipping the scales at an estimated 300 calories, this delectable confection offers a touch more energy than its more restrained counterparts.

The innate sweetness of the Cinnamon Raisin Bagel is a culinary marvel in and of itself, but when adorned with a velvety layer of cream cheese, a luscious smear of peanut butter, or a delicate drizzle of honey, the experience transcends the ordinary, elevating into a sensorial waltz that celebrates the delightful interplay of taste and texture.

This charming bagel stands as a testament to the allure of sweetness, weaving an irresistible tapestry of flavors that serenades the senses.

The Sesame Seed bagel
The Sesame Seed bagel.

Sesame Bagel

The Sesame Bagel stands as a loving homage to the cherished sesame seed, crafting a masterful union of warm, toasty flavors and a delightful, irresistible crunch. As the alluring scent of golden, toasted sesame seeds permeates the air, it conjures images of comforting mornings, unhurried conversations over brunch, and moments of pure, gastronomic contentment.

At approximately 275 calories, this bagel delivers a gratifying dose of sustenance, perfect for those seeking a touch more satisfaction from their breakfast fare.

The Sesame Bagel’s versatility is one of its greatest strengths, offering a magnificent tableau for the culinary artist. Whether adorned with a silky layer of classic cream cheese, the rich, smoky notes of smoked salmon, or the vibrant tang of goat cheese, this bagel emerges as a platform for boundless flavor combinations and gastronomic adventures.

With its nutty nuances and captivating crunch, the Sesame Bagel stands as a testament to the allure of simplicity, evoking a sense of comfort and familiarity that speaks to the heart.

The Poppy Seed bagel
The Poppy Seed bagel.

Poppy Seed

Marked by its unmistakable appearance and tantalizing flavor profile, the Poppy Seed Bagel is a formidable presence in the bagel world. Adorned with a multitude of tiny, black seeds, this bagel boasts a delicate, nutty essence and a delightful crunch that distinguishes it from its brethren.

Clocking in at around 270 calories per serving, this bagel presents itself as a gratifying option for those in pursuit of a breakfast that lingers, providing energy and satisfaction throughout the morning.

The Poppy Seed Bagel’s charm extends beyond its aesthetics, proving to be a versatile companion to a wide spectrum of spreads and toppings. Whether sweet or savory, this bagel’s unique character shines through when coupled with a rich, velvety cream cheese, the nutty goodness of almond butter, or even a bold, zesty vegetable spread.

A true testament to the beauty of variety, the Poppy Seed Bagel stands as a celebration of individuality, offering a symphony of flavors and textures that enthrall the senses and elevate the humble bagel to new heights.

From the unassuming Plain Bagel to the bold and adventurous Everything Bagel, these five popular bagel varieties offer something for every palate. The Cinnamon Raisin Bagel’s sweet allure, the Sesame Bagel’s nutty essence, and the Poppy Seed Bagel’s distinctive crunch all contribute to the rich tapestry of flavors that make bagels such an enduring favorite.

So, why not embark on a bagel odyssey and sample each of these mouthwatering masterpieces? Whether you’re a purist who cherishes the understated elegance of the Plain Bagel or an adventurous foodie eager to try the Everything Bagel’s melange of flavors, there’s a bagel out there just waiting to be discovered, devoured, and adored.

As you savor each bite, remember that these humble rings of dough represent a culinary legacy that spans centuries and continents. The bagel, in all its delectable forms, is a testament to the power of simple ingredients and the enduring appeal of tradition.

What’s your personal favorite?

About the author

Latest posts

  • Bagel And Lox Charcuterie Board

    Bagel And Lox Charcuterie Board

    Have you ever stumbled upon the culinary delight that is a Bagel and Lox Charcuterie Board? If not, allow me to whisk you away on a gastronomic journey. Picture a board — not just any board — but a grand platter overflowing with an array of bagels, lox and a multitude of other tantalizing ingredients.…

    Read more

  • What Side Dishes Go With Bagels?

    What Side Dishes Go With Bagels?

    Bagels. Those delightful, doughy circles of joy that have become a breakfast staple in many parts of the world. But have you ever stopped to consider what side dishes go with bagels? It’s a question worth pondering. After all, the right side dish can elevate your bagel from a simple snack to a gastronomic delight.…

    Read more

  • LNB Grovestand

    LNB Grovestand

    As far as delis go, we get asked about this one almost as much as NY Bagel and Deli. LNB Grovestand is considered a hidden gem in Miami that promises a delightful experience for all who visit. It’s not really as much as deli as it is a family farm. Since 1980, they’ve featured tasty…

    Read more